Hello, I realize this post is over a year old, but I’m new to this site and thought I’d give my thoughts. I recently bought by F, and that cup holder cover piece wash scratched. I can’t remember the exact cost, but it was super cheap to order a new part (I was to say like $50 or $75 US, but can’t remember exactly) and easy labor for the dealer (I was getting a couple of other things done and the dealer didn’t even charge me labor to pop off the old piece and pop on the new piece). Hopefully that will fix the issue. If not, I understand the underside piece is more expensive because you’d have to replace the whole center console. I’m sure this isn’t the first time Jag has had this issue, so hopefully they can get it resolved for you.